The Oscars are meant to celebrate the very best of cinema. Every year, we sit through the long speeches and the political grandstanding because we love the magic of the movies. But there is one segment that always tugs at the heartstrings more than any other: the In Memoriam tribute. It is a moment to pause and honor the icons who shaped our lives. However, recent omissions have sparked a heated debate. Is the Academy doing enough to recognize the global nature of film?
Take the most recent ceremony. While the stage was filled with messages about global unity and political calls for peace, a massive figure in international cinema was notably absent. Dharmendra, a titan of Indian cinema who passed away last November, did not receive a mention during the broadcast. For millions of fans across the globe, this was more than just a simple oversight. It felt like a dismissal of a legacy that spanned decades and influenced countless filmmakers.
Why the snub matters
The Academy often markets itself as the ultimate global authority on film. Yet, when it comes to honoring those we have lost, the list frequently feels restricted to a very specific Hollywood bubble. Here is why we need a change:
- Cinema is borderless. In an era where international films are winning Best Picture, our tributes should reflect that diversity.
- Cultural impact is subjective. A star might not be a household name in Los Angeles, but they could be a hero to billions elsewhere.
- Technical mastery deserves respect. It is not just about the faces on screen. Legends from all departments across the globe deserve their flowers.
We saw plenty of activism on the red carpet this year. Celebrities used their platforms to talk about war and justice. Host Conan O’Brien and various presenters touched on the importance of international collaboration. This shows that the industry wants to be seen as socially conscious and globally connected. If that is the case, why can we not extend that same consciousness to how we curate our history?
A better way forward
The In Memoriam segment should not be a popularity contest based on North American box office numbers. We need a more inclusive approach that consults international film bodies to ensure that legends like Dharmendra are not forgotten. If the Oscars want to remain relevant in a globalized world, they must stop looking inward. It is time to honor the artists who moved the world, regardless of which language they spoke or which industry they called home. Cinema belongs to everyone, and its final farewell should reflect that truth.
